Reality examine: Trump makes a bunch of false claims after occasion about defending seniors

Spread the love



Requested about his earlier compliments for China’s response to the virus, Trump falsely urged that the compliments had all come earlier than the virus arrived within the US and earlier than he had finalized a commerce take care of China. And he dubiously urged that he had rapidly solved coronavirus testing issues, although many public well being specialists say he was sluggish to react and that the nation remains to be removed from a adequate variety of assessments.

Trump repeated some outdated favourite inaccuracies about his journey restrictions on China and Europe (they weren’t full bans), commerce with China (it isn’t true that the US had by no means beforehand obtained any cash from China) and the Veterans Alternative well being care program (President Barack Obama, not Trump, signed it into legislation).

Trump additionally made a subjective declare that the US’s per capita coronavirus loss of life numbers are “very robust.” The US doesn’t have the worst numbers on this planet, nevertheless it has performed far worse than another international locations — together with South Korea, which had its first confirmed case proper across the similar time in January.

Trump claimed once more that South Korean President Moon Jae-in had known as him to go with the administration’s work on coronavirus testing after which stated, “The testing and the masks and all the issues: We have solved each downside. We solved it rapidly.” Moon’s administration advised CNN that it will not talk about the contents of their conversations.

Information First: “Solved” is questionable at finest, whereas “rapidly” is doubtful at finest. Many public well being specialists have stated that the administration was far too sluggish to make sure numerous Individuals might be examined for the virus. Many continue to say that the US is nonetheless not conducting practically sufficient assessments to permit for a protected lifting of pandemic restrictions. Republican governors continued to complain about testing issues greater than three months after the primary confirmed US case in January. And Dr. Anthony Fauci told CNN’s Jake Tapper on Tuesday that it’ll not be till “we get in the direction of the tip of Might, the start of June” that everybody who wants a check may be capable of get one.

Fauci, director of the Nationwide Institute of Allergy and Infectious Ailments, made clear that it isn’t a certainty that even this timeline can be met. He stated: “That is what I am being advised by the people who find themselves answerable for the testing. I take them for his or her phrase. If that does not occur, I’ll go to them and say, ‘What occurred right here, why did not it occur and the way can we repair it?’ ”

A number of Republican governors stated final week that they had been experiencing shortages in provides that prevented them from doing sufficient assessments.

Trump’s compliments for China

When CNN chief White Home correspondent Jim Acosta requested Trump about the truth that he had beforehand been complimentary of China’s response to the virus and requested Trump what has modified since then, Trump invoked his commerce negotiations with China.

In the course of the negotiations, Trump stated, he was complimentary of China, although he was additionally generally not. However after he made the deal, he continued, “Hastily, we heard there is a virus, and a virus is coming in. That modifications my thoughts very tremendously. That is an entire totally different factor.”

When one other reporter adopted up later within the occasion, Trump stated, “Properly, I am making a commerce take care of China. This was earlier than the virus — in fact I’ll be complimentary.” He stated that “the underside line is, we ended up making a deal earlier than the virus got here, and I used to be very proud of the deal, however then in a while, that was outdated by a virus that ought to not have occurred.”

Information First: Trump’s timeline was inaccurate. The President continued to go with China’s response to the virus after he signed the commerce settlement on January 15, after the presence of the virus in america was confirmed on January 21 and after the settlement took impact on February 14.

For instance, talking to reporters on February 18, Trump stated, “I feel President Xi is working very arduous” and “doing it very professionally.” Requested if he trusted information coming from China, Trump praised Xi Jinping once more: “Look, I do know this: President Xi loves the folks of China, he loves his nation and he is doing an excellent job with a really, very robust scenario.”

Talking to reporters on February 23, Trump was requested if Xi must be doing something otherwise in his dealing with of the disaster. He responded: “No, I feel President Xi is working very, very arduous. I spoke to him. He is working very arduous. I feel he is doing an excellent job. It is a large downside. However President Xi loves his nation. He is working very arduous to unravel the issue, and he’ll remedy the issue. OK?”

You may learn extra right here about Trump’s earlier reward of China and Xi over the virus.

Demise totals

Trump asserted that in contrast with different international locations, the US has a “very robust” variety of coronavirus deaths per million folks.

“Our loss of life totals, our numbers, per million folks, are actually very, very robust. We’re very happy with the job we have performed,” the President stated.

Information First: The US has 192 reported coronavirus deaths per million as of Thursday night. Whereas that is not essentially the most recorded coronavirus deaths per million, it additionally not the least. International locations together with Belgium, Spain and Italy have had extra deaths as a share of inhabitants, whereas international locations together with South Korea, which had its first confirmed case across the similar time because the US, have had far fewer. (It is essential to notice that there are questions in regards to the accuracy of figures from international locations around the globe, each due to suspicions of information manipulation by international locations like China and since early loss of life counts are imprecise.)

Primarily based on information from the Johns Hopkins College Heart for Programs Science and Engineering, different international locations, equivalent to Belgium, Spain and Italy, have reported extra coronavirus-related deaths per million in contrast with the US determine of 192 reported coronavirus deaths per million.
As The Washington Publish’s Glenn Kessler first pointed out, South Korea and the US each had their first reported circumstances of coronavirus in mid-January. However the US has recorded 192 folks useless per million folks, whereas South Korea has recorded fewer than 5 per million. And Singapore, which has seen circumstances spike this month, has 2.5 deaths per million. Australia has had four deaths per million.
It is essential to notice that coronavirus deaths in different international locations have generally been adjusted, and a few specialists have questioned whether or not sure international locations, notably China, are recording correct loss of life tolls. Earlier this month, China revised its official loss of life toll from the coronavirus, elevating the variety of fatalities attributed to the pandemic by greater than a 3rd.
And a Wall Avenue Journal report revealed earlier this month highlighted issues in regards to the official loss of life depend in Italy, one other nation hit arduous by the coronavirus. The nation’s depend may not have included extra coronavirus deaths amongst teams that had been by no means examined.

Journey restrictions on China and Europe

Trump as soon as once more stated his administration put a “ban” on China and Europe, utilizing the journey insurance policies as his major protection in opposition to criticism of his response to the pandemic.

“As you understand, very early on in January, we put the ban on in China,” he stated Thursday, earlier than including, “Then we later put the ban on in Europe.”

Information First: Trump’s characterization of those journey restrictions as a “ban” is deceptive as a result of each insurance policies contained a number of exemptions, together with for US residents and everlasting residents; the Europe coverage exempted total international locations. Solely overseas nationals who had been in China, Europe’s Schengen space, the UK or Eire inside the previous 14 days had been outright banned from coming into the US. And whereas the journey restrictions on China had been introduced on the finish of January, the rules didn’t go into impact till February 2.

You may learn extra in regards to the journey restrictions right here.

Tariff income and China

Touting his commerce coverage with China, Trump repeated an everyday false declare that till he took workplace, “China by no means gave our nation something. China gave us nothing. Not 10 cents.”

Information First: Examine after research has proven that Individuals, not China, are paying most of the price of Trump’s tariffs. Except for that, it isn’t true that the Treasury had by no means beforehand obtained “10 cents” or had gotten “nothing” from tariffs on China. The US has had tariffs on China for greater than two centuries. FactCheck.org reported that the US generated an “common of $12.three billion in customized duties a yr from 2007 to 2016, in keeping with the U.S. Worldwide Commerce Fee DataWeb.”
Trump was additionally fallacious if he was speaking broadly about Chinese language spending on American merchandise. China bought greater than $100 billion price of American exports from 2011 to 2016, and billions per yr relationship again to not less than 1985.

Veterans Alternative

Discussing efforts to assist veterans and senior residents, Trump once more claimed credit score for the passage of the Veterans Alternative well being care program.

With Veterans Affairs Secretary Robert Wilkie within the viewers, the President stated: “And we’re being helped very tremendously by the passage of all of the issues that we bought handed, Robert, particularly Alternative, so that folks can go and see their physician after they must and particularly our seniors.”

Information First: The Veterans Alternative invoice was a bipartisan initiative led by Sens. Bernie Sanders and the late John McCain, which was signed into legislation by President Barack Obama in 2014. In 2018, Trump signed the VA Mission Act, which expanded and adjusted this system.



Leave a Reply

Specify Twitter Consumer Key and Secret in Super Socializer > Social Login section in admin panel for Twitter Login to work

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *